Former Clark County Sheriff Jamey Noel is set to spend nearly a decade in prison after pleading guilty to multiple felony charges, including theft and money laundering.
Noel admitted to misusing millions of dollars intended for fire and EMS departments and will now pay back over $3.1 million to various state agencies. His sentencing on Monday brings a significant part of this long-standing case to a close, though other investigations into his actions continue.
Originally charged with 31 felonies, Noel pleaded guilty to 27, including corruption, obstruction, and tax evasion. Victims described in court how Noel’s actions put public safety at risk, with first responders lacking proper equipment under his leadership.
Roger Montgomery Jr., a former colleague, testified that Noel prioritized profit over 911 calls, endangering citizens by assigning emergency personnel to drive his personal vehicles. Montgomery argued that Noel had betrayed public trust for personal gain.
Noel appeared in court shackled, expressing remorse and accepting responsibility for his actions. He received a 15-year sentence, with three years suspended to probation.
He could serve about nine-and-a-half years if he maintains good behavior. Additionally, Noel must repay $2.9 million to the Utica Volunteer Firefighters Association, along with other amounts to the Indiana Department of Revenue and Indiana State Police. Special Judge Larry Medlock also imposed a $270,000 fine.
Noel’s legal issues began after state investigators raided his home, revealing he had used public funds for personal expenses like cars, vacations, and college tuition.
Among assets seized were rare classic cars, including two 1970 Plymouth Superbirds and other vintage vehicles. Court documents also revealed Noel’s diversion of public funds to support political campaigns, totaling $33,000.
In addition to the criminal case, Noel faces multiple civil lawsuits. Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita is seeking to recover more funds through lawsuits, alleging Noel misused over $900,000 from the Clark County jail commissary fund.
A court has prohibited Noel’s family from selling assets until these civil cases are resolved.
Noel’s wife and daughter also face charges of theft and tax evasion. Both have pleaded not guilty, and their trial date was recently postponed.
Meanwhile, Noel’s potential public pensions remain uncertain. Although his state police service may not qualify him, he could retain county-level benefits.
Noel’s association with Indiana politics is extensive, having served as a campaign chair for Governor Eric Holcomb.
Holcomb stated in August that he would not issue a pardon for Noel, emphasizing that such a review process would occur far down the line, well beyond his term.
As investigations continue, Special Prosecutor Ric Hertel focuses on securing restitution and resolving asset claims.
Noel’s case has left a lasting impact on Clark County, with the community grappling with the consequences of his misconduct.
